Gifts Image

Guns & the NRA

Nov 25, 2018 | American, Canadian, Life&Food, World News

QR Link

GoldFish QR Code

Preparation
CONSIDER

Have you ever held a real gun?

MP3

Right click this link to download the mp3.

PDF

Right click this link to download a printable PDF file for this conversation.

Transcript
This is a continuation of a conversation Yohanes and José were having about the gun violence problem in America. See the first part at the URL below: REMOVING GUNS

http://goldfish365.com/accents/canadian/removingguns/

Yohanes Handojo: Why get rid of guns? Like we already have them. Other people have them already. You know, I’m not going to sacrifice my now for other people’s future. And I think that’s, that’s the reason people think like that in America.

José Cruz: So you’re you’re thinking that in general the the the psychological uh, environment of America um, at this point is still pretty similar to what it was before and it’s it’s not conducive to letting people see uh uh the rationality of giving up these weapons.

Yohanes: Yeah yeah (Right?) and it’s it’s more like because they put so much value in instant gratification, they don’t think about the future. They don’t think about- You know, it- When I- when I came here and people actually have different trash cans for different things…

José: Ah me too! My house too!

Yohanes: Different um- and and you know uh, you take out the- these trashes (oh the separation of the garbage) Yeah right right right. And that’s completely inconvenient. That is totally inconvenient. For- Ha ha. And and I see your face right now.

José: I’m de- yeah, I’m listening. I’m listening.

Yohanes: It it’s- and and the reason I think that is because, in America you just throw away everything (You don’t do that) Nobody (That’s right) nobody does that. Um sure you um you take out the trash and you know there’s like cardboard and there’s recyclables, and stuff like that. But no one really does that. Like people don’t- people don’t bother themselves enough to do those things. And yet over here it’s a way of life. People actually do that.

José: But when you saw it, you go, “That’s a good idea!” Right?

Yohanes: That is a great idea!

José: See! Yeah see! But you’re thinking, so that’s the sort of thing that just wouldn’t take off in America? (Right) See that’s where I would disagree with you. Now let me explain why (OK) Um, I understand what you’re saying about you know, instant gratification and all of these psychological bases for, (Mm) for why America doesn’t want to give up these weapons. (Right) I mean honestly, you’ve probably been to a range and you’ve shot a gun, right? (No) You’ve never? Have you ever held a real gun in your hand? (Yes) OK It feels nice right? (Ha ha um) It makes you feel like, it’s almost sexy, right?

Yohanes: It is it is quite sexy actually. (Isn’t it) Yeah yeah.

José: And the the whole idea- I don’t know if it’s a phallic thing or whatever, but it’s um, it makes you feel power. It makes you feel psychologically powerful (Definitely definitely) So I think a lot of the things you’re talking about, I think, and this is where I think you and I can agree. Humans are humans (Yeah) and the concept of instant gratification and the problem of it isn’t unique to America.

Yohanes: And oh yeah yeah. Definitely definitely.

José: We we had the same problem in Canada (Mm hmm) and in Japan more so the problem here (Right) instant gratification. And yet somehow, in most of these G8 or G20 countries there were rational approaches to most problems. (Right) But if we’re only talking about guns- and it seems like America can be quite irrational, but it has rational answers to to a lot of other problems beyond guns, but (Right) why only guns? And if you ask yourself the question, “Why isJosé should have said, “are” (2:59) guns the big problem?” You can look at it and say from a psych- you know a psych majora (university) student of psychology (3:03)’s point of view, (Yup) “Well psych- psychologically it’s this and this and that.” But (Mm) you’d have to be comparative and say well look at Canada, (Right yeah) do they have those same problems? (Right right right) They do. They do have those same problems. And we have the same number of people who probably would like to have the same kind of gun laws in Canada (Right) as you have in America but why don’t we have that problem? Well I look at that from the Poli-Scishort for “Political Science”, a field of academic study (3:23) (Mm) point of view and you look at what changed in the last mm few decades (Right) to create the problem that you have now that you didn’t have (Yeah) back in (Yeah) you know, when the Second AmendmentThe Second Amendment of the American Constitution. See the VOA article in the References (3:35) was just the Second Amendment (Yeah) uh and and you can find the answer probably around the, mid-sixties mid-seventies (Right) When the NRAThe National Rifle Association. See the VOA article in the References (3:45) finally realized, hey, you know, we can be this sportsman’s organization when we’re- (Right) The NRA used to lobby for gun control.

Yohanes: That is, that is quite interesting. Yeah.

José: Um they they used to say that we need stricter control of guns. Because you know, mentally retarded people shouldn’t have guns. (Yeah) Silencers? that’s crazy thing. People don’t need silencers. (Yeah) And now they’ve turned it completely around. (Yeah right) Well when did that happen? They were taken over by the gun industry. (Right) By by the moneyed interests.

Consolidation
DISCUSSION

Would a gun make you powerful?

Do you agree with the NRA slogan that, “Guns don’t kill people, people kill people”?

Note how José makes sure he understands Yohanes’ argument before he brings his counter argument. This style of discussion is called the “Steel Man Argument”.


VOA article

Americans Debating Gun Control

Image Courtesy

MasterTux

Take the quiz

QR Link

Access this article on your mobile device

GoldFish QR Code

GoldFish Audio cover

Speakers

NEW Image

Yohanes Handojo

American

Jakarta, Indonesia

José Domingo Cruz image

José Domingo Cruz

Canadian

Vancouver, British Columbia


Statistics

  • 832 words (including pause words)
  • 4:17 minutes in the mp3 audio
  • 194.24 words per minute for this article



Spritz

To spritz only part of this conversation, highlight the text you want and click the “SPRITZ NOW!” button. Clicking the button without any text highlighted will spritz the entire page.

To quickly adjust the words per minute (wpm), you can use the left and right arrow keys.






Continue practicing your English fluency with the related posts above, or navigate to other authentic conversations using the Previous and Next buttons below.





Writing comments will help your English writing skills. Feel free to ask questions and share opinions. We try to respond to all comments we get on the site.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This

Share This

Share this post with your friends!